skip to main content
return to Gazette front page about the Gazette publication schedule links complete contents search the Gazette; browse back issues
more stories news briefs faculty and staff news photos

Remembering the civil rights leader: Annual Memorial for Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.

Faculty Council brings focus to 'Difficult Dialogues'

Bird flu web site provides updates, health information


(919) 962-7124
FAX (919) 962-2279

The Gazette staff is always looking for ideas for interesting feature stories. Do you have one to share?

University Gazette


Faculty Council News

It’s an age-old challenge made more daunting in a climate overheated from the current culture wars: How do people tackle difficult questions without becoming difficult in the process? How do people learn to attack issues without attacking people with whom they

This challenge was a central topic of conversation at the Jan. 20 Faculty Council as members heard details about the Difficult Dialogues initiative.

The Ford Foundation created the grants to help institutions develop programs designed to enrich learning, encourage new scholarship and engage students and faculty in constructive dialogue about contentious political, religious, racial and cultural issues.

Carolina was one of 27 higher education institutions the Ford Foundation selected in December to received grants of $100,000 each. The universities will use the money for projects that promote campus environments where sensitive subjects can be discussed in a spirit of scholarly inquiry, academic freedom and with respect for different viewpoints.

To hear more about the initiative, go to

Specifically, the University campus will work to develop discussion and moderator materials around the issue of “how religious belief and intellectual inquiry intersect at a public university setting.”

Finding an acceptable answer to the question has grown in urgency since Sept. 11, 2001, and the series of campus controversies that involved religion in some way.

The first incident occurred in the summer of 2002 when the Family Policy Network failed in its legal attempt to block Carolina’s selection of “Approaching the Qur’án: the Early Revelations” for its summer reading program.

In 2003, another constitutional issue evolving academic freedom and faith emerged when a three-member Christian fraternity lost its status as an officially recognized student organization when it refused to sign the University’s standard non-discrimination policy.

In spring of 2004, another furor over faith and freedom erupted when an English instructor was disciplined for publicly accusing a student of hate speech when he spoke out in class about his objection to homosexuality based on religious beliefs.

A steering committee was developed in spring of 2005 in response to the Ford Foundation’s initial call for proposals. The steering committee has said the impetus behind its proposal to the Ford Foundation was to counter efforts to polarize the campus community and to promote civil, informed and productive discourse.

During his State of the University address last year, Chancellor James Moesere underlined his dedication to the goals of the initiative when he said, “This University was created at the beginning of the American republic to be a laboratory for democracy. We can show America how to have civil discourse about difficult topics.”

In his remarks before Faculty Council, Moeser praised Faculty Chair Judith Wegner and English professor William Andrews who served as the co-principal investigators for the Ford grant.

Moeser said Carolina is the right place to be having a conversation on the interface between religious expression and academic freedom. Carolina’s selection to participate in the Difficult Dialogue initiative, he said, presented an opportunity for Carolina to show leadership in this national conversation on how to approach difficult issues in an atmosphere of civility and respect.

Wegner, a consultant with the National Issues Forums Network that uses materials produced by the Kettering Foundation of Dayton, Ohio, that offers a model for civil public discourse on sensitive issues. (For more information, visit

Holt, a professor emerita from the University of Georgia, said the key word in the approach is “deliberation” as opposed to debate.

The object of the approach is to frame issues in such a way that participants can see and weigh other perspectives and other approaches to addressing an issue. Holt played a short film on different viewpoints and strategies related to immigration into the United States.

Even before work began on the application for the Ford grant, though, the University had already started developing programs to bring matters of religious faith into the realm of academic inquiry.

In 2002-03, for instance, the University’s Society of Fellows (doctoral graduate students from a variety of disciplines) organized a forum on “Faith and Public Life: An Exploration of the Relationship between Private Religious Belief and Public Policy.”

In summer of 2004, the University’s Center for Teaching and Learning, supported by the Academy of Distinguished Scholars and the Faculty Council, began campus workshops and offered web publications on “Teaching Controversial Subjects” and “Managing Classroom Conflict.”

In spring of 2005, the Johnston Center for Undergraduate Excellence hosted a cross-disciplinary symposium titled “Is there a Tomorrow? — Rapture, Extinction and Democracy.” Also in 2005, Carolina became one of the first public colleges in the country to establish a minor in the “Study of Christian Cultures.” That same year, sociology professor Christian Smith conducted a National Study of Youth and Religion that examined the influence of religion and spirituality in the lives of adolescents.

This spring, the Program on the Humanities and Human Values will hold a weekend seminar for UNC alumni and friends on “The Book of Genesis, Evolution and Social Conflict.”

Return to Top
   FREE Hit Counter