TABLE OF CONTENTS  |  FRONT PAGE  |  NEXT ARTICLE |  PREVIOUS ARTICLE  |  UNC HOMEPAGE

Water expert says: Stop stepping on nature's flow


Thomas Cahill drove into Chapel Hill July 24 with his head in the clouds. Rain clouds that is.

It was a Monday morning and, the night before, there had been yet another gully washer of a storm that had led to the subject Cahill had come to Carolina to talk about: surface water, and what has to be done to manage it.

He surveyed mud-covered parking lots, checked out floodwater in Eastgate Shopping Center and nodded his head. Beneath Eastgate's parking lot was a culvert through which developers had tried to squeeze a section of a natural stream. During the night of heavy rain, it had squeezed out with nowhere to go but the parking lot above.

"I just loved it. I was probably the only happy face around," Cahill said two days later as he stood before a group of faculty and staff at a meeting of campus teams working on Carolina's master plan.

What Cahill had witnessed could be used as evidence to make his case for why designs for stormwater management must be incorporated into the campus master plan.

As part of its master plan work, Ayers Saint Gross hired the firms of Andropogon Associates and Cahill Associates, both from the Philadelphia area, to collaborate on developing an environmental master plan. Ayers Saint Gross is the main consultant leading efforts to develop a new master plan.

The environmental master plan is being guided by an advisory committee of Carolina experts, including Phil Berke, associate professor of city and regional planning, and others familiar with N.C. laws and practices regarding stormwater.

Andropogon is a landscape architecture firm known for ecological master planning and sustainable design, including the restoration and management of natural habitats.

Cahill Associates specializes in water resources engineering and is a leader in innovative stormwater management.

The most obvious way to prevent the problems he'd seen at Eastgate is to limit development within watershed areas, Cahill said.

Another way to limit runoff is to build parking lots made out of porous concrete or asphalt, which allows rainwater to seep through the surface. The surfaces would be underlined with a bed of stones with the capacity to store excess water for days when the soil below it is saturated.

The water management plan being developed is for the central campus and the Mason Farm tract -- including Finley Golf Course -- the North Carolina Botanical Garden and the Friday Center area. The recommendations will be integrated into the campus master plan before it is presented for approval to the University Board of Trustees this fall.

Jonathan Howes, the co-chair of the campus advisory committee overseeing the process, said the master plan calls for the redevelopment of south campus to include more residence halls and academic functions, but it was initially drawn without much thought given to the area's steep slopes and streams.

What the consultants found was that streams carried stormwater from substantial watersheds subject to protection under tough environmental laws.

What that will mean is that buildings that had been envisioned along some of these slopes must go elsewhere. The good news is that none of the buildings had yet been linked with any particular department or use, Howes said.

The needed adjustments will have no effect on the four residence halls planned for the intersection of Manning Drive and Skipper Bowles Drive.

"At the moment, I don't think there will be a net reduction of square footage," Howes said. "We're just going to have to be more attentive to the management of stormwater and the preservation of these historic streams."

Thanks to tough new environmental rules, it is no longer a question of aesthetics over practicality.

"Complying with new state and federal regulations is not an option, it's the law," Howes said. "The manner in which compliance is achieved is the challenge for us, and the opportunity. That's the good part about it. There are lots of ways to do this."

For instance, remnants of the old forests that existed at the time the University was built lie along portions of the stream slopes. The master plan now calls for a commons area near the spring where some of the streams originate.

This kind of preservation will enhance the network of pedestrian footpaths that the master plan has called for all along. "It's certainly possible that more areas will now be along a forested stream bank rather than an area stripped of most of its natural beauty," Howes said.

Cahill said that land use planning and water resources management used to be done independently of each other. Now, each must be done in concert to keep in harmony -- growth balanced with conservation, buildings made to fit within nature rather than take its place.

The overwhelming challenge is the excess stormwater runoff created by development. It is intuitively obvious that when you bulldoze the land and cover it with asphalt you have created an impenetrable wall between the rain and the earth that prevents the rain from seeping slowly through the soil, through cracks in the bedrock and into underground water systems that flow into and "recharge" surface streams and lakes.

The N. C. Piedmont gets an average of 45 inches of rain a year, Cahill said. Half of it will evaporate. In natural conditions, about one-eighth will run off. The rest seeps into the ground at a rate of 1,100 gallons per acre per day, provided that acre is still in a natural state.

The traditional development tool to dispose of runoff has been to run it downhill through drainage systems, Cahill said. But that doesn't work. The water carries surface pollutants ranging from car oil to yard fertilizer into streams, lakes or manmade retention ponds.

And when too much rain falls, the water spills over into streets and yards the same way water will spill out of a cup when kept under a faucet too long.

The parking deck serving Kenan-Flagler Business School, just as the parking lot at Eastgate, sits atop a stream. Cahill said he had gone to the business school, stood above a drain in the parking deck and looked down. He could see the water rushing past, hear it gurgling as if gasping for air.

"You can put a stream in pipe and pave over it and put cars on top, but the stream still lives," Cahill said.


TABLE OF CONTENTS  |  FRONT PAGE  |  NEXT ARTICLE |  PREVIOUS ARTICLE  |  UNC HOMEPAGE